Introduction to Strategic Management

Original descriptive practice: 30 saved, 3 at 3 marks, 21 at 5 and 6 at 10. Management, strategy and its proactive/reactive mix; importance and limitations; intent, vision, mission, objectives and values; corporate/business/functional roles and relationship networks. Original applied practice, not ICAI questions or official marking schemes. Native tables scroll on phones. Original preparation is not a live or complete official question bank.

Boundaries: Page 19 uses future-oriented mission language, unlike the present-scope distinction on pages 14/17. Page 27 uses loose manager labels; decision scope governs classification. Historical company examples are not current verified claims. No strategy or relationship network guarantees success.

SM-C01-D001 · 3 marks

Mira says management means only the directors. A plant supervisor plans work, assigns staff and checks defects. Explain the two uses of management and apply them. (3 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1GroupManagement names the people responsible for integrating the firm's resources; directors are part of this group, not its entire scope.
1ProcessPlanning, organising, staffing, directing and control are interrelated functions, not only a board title.
1ApplicationThe supervisor performs management processes through work plans, staff assignment and defect checks even without being a director.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 3

SM-C01-D002 · 5 marks

A repair firm buys software and tools but leaves workers untrained and dispatch uncoordinated. Explain how management can turn these resources into a functioning whole. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1IntegrationMoney, materials, people and technology must work together; tools alone do not deliver repairs.
1PlanningSet service targets and capacity before buying more equipment.
1Organising/staffingAssign dispatch ownership, train technicians and match skills to jobs.
1DirectionExplain priorities and coordinate software use with field workers.
1Control/adaptationTrack completion/defects and adjust schedules or training; possession of resources does not prove effective use.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 3

SM-C01-D003 · 5 marks

A board announces double sales but gives no customer choice, investment path or competitive plan. Explain what is missing from a strategy. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1DirectionThe target gives a desired result but not a long-range direction connecting goals and means.
1PositionSpecify customers, needs and how the firm will compete, not only revenue.
1IntegrationLink product, production, marketing and resources into a consistent plan.
1ActionIdentify choices, priorities and responsibilities rather than a slogan.
1AdaptationAllow revision when assumptions fail; a sales target does not guarantee success.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 4

SM-C01-D004 · 5 marks

After a port closes unexpectedly, Atlas replaces a planned export route while keeping its chosen customer segment. Does the change prove it has no strategy? Explain. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1JudgmentNo. A strategy is flexible and pragmatic, not a flawless fixed script.
1ContinuityIts customer segment and broad direction can continue while a route changes.
1ReactionThe closure is an unanticipated development requiring adaptive action.
1ChoiceCompare alternative routes, costs and service consequences within the original purpose.
1LimitA response still needs responsible management; flexibility is not permission to try unrelated actions blindly.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 5

SM-C01-D005 · 10 marks

A bakery group planned a low-sugar line, continues a successful subscription model, cancels an uneconomic kiosk and adds home delivery after an unexpected local closure. Analyse its actual strategy and justify how it should review these choices. (10 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
2ProactiveThe planned low-sugar launch deliberately anticipates customer needs. Link formulation to research and feasible resources rather than assuming demand.
2Continued elementsThe working subscription model remains an ongoing element from prior periods. Retention depends on evidence that it still supports the chosen position.
2ReactiveDelivery after the unexpected closure is an adaptive response, even though executing it now requires planning. Classify by the trigger, not by whether a written plan exists.
2Abandoned elementsThe cancelled kiosk is not part of the latest actual strategy. Its sunk history should not force continued spending; assess current costs and service coverage.
2Integrated reviewThe current strategy blends retained/planned and reactive elements. Review performance and changed assumptions together; neither purely proactive nor purely reactive is guaranteed best.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 6

SM-C01-D006 · 3 marks

A hospital supplier studies possible future stock disruptions and signs backup agreements before any disruption. Another changes vendors only after an unanticipated shutdown. Classify the two actions and state the limit. (3 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1FirstBackup agreements based on anticipated scenarios are proactive/planned actions.
1SecondVendor change prompted by an unforeseen shutdown is reactive/adaptive action.
1LimitA firm may combine both; preparation does not eliminate uncertainty and reaction is not automatically failure.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 6

SM-C01-D007 · 5 marks

A tutoring firm writes a vision and stops. Results weaken, but managers say strategy is finished. Explain the process steps that remain. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1AnalysisExamine internal capabilities and external changes, not only the statement.
1ObjectivesTranslate direction into realistic measurable targets.
1ChoiceCreate and choose a plan relating market needs to resources.
1ImplementationAssign tasks and resources and execute the chosen plan.
1Evaluation/correctionMeasure outcomes, investigate gaps and revise; strategic management is cyclical, not a one-time document.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 8

SM-C01-D008 · 5 marks

A clinic claims a colourful logo is its advantage, while patients value appointment reliability. Explain how strategic management can guide a better advantage without promising it will always win. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1ValueAdvantage concerns something unique and valued by the customer; a logo may not satisfy that requirement.
1EvidenceEstablish whether patients actually value reliable appointments and how competitors perform.
1ResourcesBuild scheduling capacity, staff routines and monitoring consistent with the promise.
1DirectionConnect the service choice to mission and performance goals rather than copying every competitor.
1LimitCompetitor response and uncertain demand remain; a strategy aims at better performance, not guaranteed dominance.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 8

SM-C01-D009 · 5 marks

A small furniture workshop plans market choice, machine investment and staff training separately. Apply five benefits of strategic management to improve their coordination. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1DirectionCommon mission and goals align which furniture customers the workshop serves.
1ProactivityAnticipate demand/capacity before machines become a bottleneck.
1Decision frameworkJudge the machine purchase and training against the same chosen market position.
1Avoid mistakesCheck fit and affordability before pursuing an attractive but unrelated product line.
1Long-term capabilityDevelop skills and reliable production that support survival; benefits are intended effects, not certainty.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 9

SM-C01-D010 · 10 marks

Reed Bookshops faces unexpected digital competition. Its owner proposes either an expensive six-month planning exercise or abandoning all strategy. Advise a proportionate approach, applying benefits and all four main limitations. (10 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
2Direction/benefitA clear customer/service position can guide product, store and digital choices. Do not abandon strategic thinking simply because a forecast was wrong.
2Turbulent environmentChanging digital demand can defeat estimates. Use alternative assumptions, monitor behaviour and revise rather than trust a static forecast.
2TimeA six-month exercise could crowd out urgent operations. Set a bounded review with short experiments and named follow-up dates.
2CostExpert research and implementation consume scarce funds. Match analysis depth to Reed's resources and the importance of the decision, without promising free expertise.
2Competitor uncertaintyRivals' private plans cannot be known exactly. Test service choices, track responses and evaluate results; proportionate strategy supports action but cannot guarantee recovery.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 11

SM-C01-D011 · 5 marks

A firm makes its premises accessible because equal access is a stated value. A manager says the decision is worthless unless it beats rivals. Assess this claim. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1JudgmentReject the claim: some decisions are worthy on their own count even without a strict competitive strategic purpose.
1ValueEqual access can guide conduct independently of a marketing return.
1Strategy distinctionAn action may support strategy, but not every management or ethical decision needs that label.
1EvaluationAssess access outcomes and feasibility rather than inventing a competitive advantage.
1LimitThis does not settle any actual legal accessibility duty or authorise expenditure; the case is conceptual.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 11

SM-C01-D012 · 3 marks

A startup repeatedly rewrites its plan but ships nothing. Identify the limitation and propose an action-oriented correction. (3 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1LimitationStrategic management can consume time and impede routine operations when analysis never becomes action.
1CorrectionAgree a clear initial choice, owner and delivery milestone, then evaluate and adapt after execution.
1BalanceDo not discard all analysis; use enough evidence for the decision while protecting operating time.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 11

SM-C01-D013 · 5 marks

Clearwater Foods states that it exists to provide affordable meals, and that it will never hide ingredients. Distinguish intent and values without ranking them as interchangeable concepts. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1IntentAffordable meals state why the business exists and what it strives to achieve.
1ValuesIngredient honesty is a principle guiding decisions and actions.
1ConnectionThe chosen purpose should be pursued within those principles.
1ConflictCheaper meals obtained by hiding ingredients would undermine the stated value even if a sales target improved.
1NuanceIntent and values differ and go together; the source's broader-values discussion is not a licence to collapse them into one definition.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 23

SM-C01-D014 · 5 marks

A learning company writes: We aim to be the trusted regional learning partner in five years; today we provide affordable evening courses for working adults using local tutors. Identify vision and mission and explain the distinction. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1VisionThe future trusted regional position describes where the firm wants to go.
1MissionThe present evening-course business explains what it does, for whom and how.
1IdentityMission gives current purpose, customer focus and capabilities.
1DirectionVision steers future choices and communicates aspiration.
1Source boundaryUse this explicit present/future distinction; PDF page 19 uses future-dream language for mission, so do not treat timing alone as an infallible label in every text.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 14

SM-C01-D015 · 10 marks

Larch Mobility currently repairs commuter bicycles through neighbourhood workshops and trained mechanics. It wants to become the region's most trusted affordable bicycle-service network by 2031. Honesty and safe repairs are non-negotiable. The fictional case supplies an illustrative 12-month plan targets reducing average repair turnaround from 3 days to 2 and reducing verified repeat defects from 4% to 2%, with the same agreed denominators. Draft vision, mission and these two measurable objectives, then explain alignment and constraints. (10 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
2VisionExample: To become the region's most trusted affordable bicycle-service network by 2031. It states a future position; trust/affordability need evidence-based measures, not a promise that leadership already exists.
2MissionExample: We keep commuter bicycles usable through neighbourhood repair workshops and trained mechanics, with honest advice and safe repairs. It names current customers, service and capabilities; it does not falsely claim an expanded network.
2Objective oneObjective: reduce average repair turnaround from 3 days to 2 within 12 months, using the same defined repairs/date convention. It connects service reliability to a measurable baseline/target/period; the illustrative plan does not prove actual feasibility.
2Objective twoObjective: reduce verified repeat defects from 4% to 2% within 12 months using the same agreed denominator. It measures quality separately from job volume; specify the responsible owner and review records, without inventing a legal quality guarantee.
2AlignmentVision supplies future direction, mission current business, objectives measurable steps and values decision limits. Resources, capability and external conditions must shape targets; honest/safe repairs cannot be discarded for short-term gain.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 16

SM-C01-D016 · 5 marks

A textile firm's proposed mission says: We do everything for everyone, perfectly, forever. Its actual business is durable uniforms for schools using local production. Evaluate and rewrite it. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1ClarityThe draft hides the actual business and customer group.
1FeasibilityPerfectly/forever and everyone are unsupported and not useful decision guides.
1DistinctivenessUniforms, schools and local production give identity that a generic slogan lacks.
1RewriteExample: We provide schools with durable uniforms through reliable local production and practical service.
1UseCheck the draft is clear, feasible, distinctive and motivating and reflects management's philosophy; it is an original proposal, not an adopted company statement.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 17

SM-C01-D017 · 5 marks

A ferry operator says its business is maintaining boats; passengers buy dependable cross-river travel. Explain production-oriented versus need-oriented definitions and the resource limit. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1ProductionMaintaining boats describes a production/resource activity rather than the whole customer need.
1NeedDependable cross-river travel supplies an external/customer-oriented business definition.
1CustomerIdentify commuter/tourist groups and the travel problem served.
1MeansBoats, crew and scheduling remain capabilities for satisfying the need, not irrelevant costs.
1ScopeA wider need definition informs opportunity search but does not justify an unsupported move into every transport business.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 19

SM-C01-D018 · 5 marks

Elm Diagnostics grows across three sites with conflicting investment requests and task ownership. Apply five purposes of a mission statement. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1UnanimityCommon purpose aligns the three sites instead of competing interpretations.
1Resource basisEvaluate investment requests against customer service and business scope.
1Motivation/identityExplain why work matters and who identifies with the organisation.
1Work structureTranslate purpose into responsible teams and tasks.
1ControlConnect purpose to cost, time and performance parameters; a statement alone does not create compliance.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 17

SM-C01-D019 · 5 marks

A retailer uses goal and objective interchangeably. One statement says improve reach; another says serve 20 new towns by 31 March 2028. Explain the practical and conceptual distinction. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1GoalImprove reach is an open-ended desired outcome.
1Objective20 towns by the stated date is more specific and time-based.
1MeasurementDefine what counts as served and a verified baseline/owner.
1RelationshipA specific objective can translate the broad goal into measurable progress.
1NuanceThe chapter also uses the words interchangeably; do not reject an otherwise correct answer solely because the organisation calls its measurable target a goal.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 19

SM-C01-D020 · 10 marks

Orion Training promises market leadership soon, doubles enrolment targets without tutors, rewards only signups and ignores completion complaints. Redesign a coherent objective set and explain how it guides appraisal. (10 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
2Specific/time-boundReplace soon with defined enrolment/quality outcomes, baseline, period and owner. Proposed targets require capacity evidence; no number is inferred as achievable from the slogan.
2Mission/environmentRelate growth to the learning service and customer needs; define the market for any leadership comparison. Objectives should strengthen the business position, not merely sound ambitious.
2Measurable/controllableTrack verified completion and service indicators as well as signups, with agreed definitions. Managers can influence training/service; they cannot fully control market conditions.
2Challenge/resourcesSet challenging but feasible staged growth within tutor/time/funding constraints. Recruit or train within an approved plan before assuming doubled capacity.
2Correlation/appraisalBalance enrolment, quality and resource objectives so incentive for signups does not damage completion. Review actual versus defined standards and investigate gaps before changing the strategy.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 20

SM-C01-D021 · 5 marks

A manufacturer aims to double sales over five years, but says annual targets are unnecessary until year four. Explain milestones and the case in which short/long targets could coincide. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1Long horizonA five-year outcome shapes what capacity/customer development must start now.
1Short milestonesAnnual/quarterly targets set the speed and intermediate results toward the outcome.
1ResourcesLink milestones to production and market-development capability rather than postponing action.
1CoincidenceIf a continuing annual target is already being attained, short and long targets may share the same level/rate.
1LimitDo not infer uniform growth, a guaranteed doubling or a universal five-year horizon; actual target paths depend on circumstances.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 21

SM-C01-D022 · 5 marks

A board monitors only profit and dismisses staff capability, relationships and public responsibility. Apply the chapter's long-term objective areas to propose a broader dashboard. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1Profit/productivityTrack financial outcome and productive resource use separately; profitable growth may still waste resources.
1Competitive positionUse a defined customer/market measure relevant to the chosen business.
1Employee development/relationsMeasure skills progress and working relationships; they are different areas, not only headcount.
1TechnologyReview relevant technological capability or leadership, without assuming every firm must invent new technology.
1Public responsibilityInclude the firm's stated social responsibilities. All seven areas are conceptual guides, not prescribed current regulatory reporting.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 21

SM-C01-D023 · 5 marks

A software firm claims integrity and accountability but hides an outage to protect this month's sales. Analyse the value conflict and a response consistent with its stated principles. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1ValuesIntegrity and accountability guide behaviour, including difficult situations.
1ConflictConcealing a known outage conflicts with the principles even if short-term sales improve.
1Action proposalInvestigate and give accurate, authorised customer information through proper channels; do not invent facts or send without scope.
1Internal effectAlign staff incentives and responsibility with truth rather than rewarding concealment.
1External effectCustomer trust and long-term relationships can be affected, but no specific legal notice duty or financial result is established by this case.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 22

SM-C01-D024 · 5 marks

A group decides to enter healthcare. Its clinic division chooses a service model. The finance manager designs billing controls. Identify each strategic level and explain why job title alone is insufficient. (5 marks)

Responsibilities supplied in the case, not real company announcements.

DecisionResponsibility scope
Enter healthcareWhole group portfolio
Choose clinic service modelOne business
Design billing controlsFinance function
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1CorporateEntering healthcare changes the group portfolio/where it competes.
1BusinessThe clinic division chooses how that business competes and serves customers.
1FunctionalBilling controls support the business strategy through the finance function.
1LinkFunctional action must align with division/group direction, with information also flowing upward.
1ScopeJudge decision responsibility and organisational context, not a title alone; the chapter's page 27 network wording conflicts with its clearer function-role explanation.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 24

SM-C01-D025 · 10 marks

Birch Group owns food and logistics divisions. The board considers acquiring a packaging company, divesting a weak operation and reallocating capital. A director wants to dictate every logistics route instead. Analyse the corporate role, shareholder link and need for business/functional input. (10 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
2PortfolioAcquisition/divestment and which businesses to be in are corporate-level choices. Review strategic fit and evidence; this case does not authorise either transaction.
2Resource allocationReallocating capital among divisions is a whole-group decision. Compare needs and expected contributions rather than favouring a division without analysis.
2Mission/leadershipCorporate managers define group direction/goals and lead cross-business strategy. They should communicate a coherent purpose so divisions can develop appropriate competitive choices.
2Ownership linkCorporate managers connect strategic management to owners and bear accountability for shareholder welfare/wealth in the chapter's model. This does not erase other duties or prove any current law.
2Role coordinationDivision managers choose concrete logistics competitive strategies and functional teams supply operating evidence/implementation. A route decision may be operational or strategically important in context, but corporate oversight is not a reason to ignore local expertise.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 25

SM-C01-D026 · 5 marks

Harbour Group operates a transport unit with its own marketing, finance and operations. Its head translates group reliability goals into a chosen commuter service and pricing approach. Explain SBU/business-level responsibilities. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1SBUA self-contained division with functions serving a particular product/service market fits the chapter's SBU description.
1TranslationTurn broad group reliability intent into a concrete business approach.
1CompetitionChoose how the commuter transport unit creates customer value/advantage.
1ResourcesPursue growth/profitability with allocated capital and operating capabilities.
1BoundaryBusiness choices differ from group portfolio scope and functional task plans; self-contained does not mean independent of corporate direction.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 25

SM-C01-D027 · 5 marks

A purchasing manager warns that a new low-price product uses unreliable components. Senior managers say functions may execute orders but never help formulate strategy. Assess their position. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1RolePurchasing is a function, so it develops supporting sourcing strategy and implements plans.
1InformationSupplier reliability evidence can make corporate/business choices realistic and attainable.
1Idea generationFunctional managers close to suppliers/operations may originate ideas that become wider strategy.
1CoordinationSenior managers should listen and test the evidence rather than dismiss it because of hierarchy.
1BoundaryInput does not transfer all portfolio authority to purchasing; scope and accountability remain differentiated.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 26

SM-C01-D028 · 5 marks

Vale has independent product divisions reporting through division heads; a small pilot team shares ideas with few hierarchy layers; a temporary launch team reports to both a project lead and its function managers. Identify all three networks and discuss fit. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1Divisional/functionalIndependent units organised by product/function use specialist heads and defined reporting relationships.
1HorizontalThe pilot emphasises flatter relationships, openness and fast idea sharing; fewer levels do not remove all decision accountability.
1MatrixThe launch team combines functions with more than one reporting manager in a grid-like project relationship.
1FitSpecialisation/clear lines suit stable units; speed suits the pilot; cross-functional launch needs can favour matrix coordination.
1Costs/limitsIsolation, unclear flat-team roles and dual-reporting conflict must be assessed. No network is universally best or exclusive to a particular firm size.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 27

SM-C01-D029 · 5 marks

A firm lets only its executive team make strategic choices while another invites frontline proposals for executive review. Compare top-down/bottom-up and recommend a case-sensitive balance. (5 marks)
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
1Top-downLeadership supplies direction and decisions; this can support consistent priorities but may miss local information.
1Bottom-upTeams across levels have a voice in ideas and decision input; participation need not remove final executive accountability.
1EvidenceUse customer/operating feedback to test feasibility.
1BalanceConnect input to clear corporate/business priorities and delegated decision rights.
1LimitNo universally better approach is established. Urgency, culture, resources and decision scope matter; consultation alone does not guarantee agreement.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 27

SM-C01-D030 · 10 marks

Juniper Services currently repairs household appliances through trained local teams. Its future aim is a trusted regional repair network by 2031; values are honest diagnosis and safe work. The board plans a second service business and capital allocation. The repair division chooses reliable scheduled service; its training head designs technician courses. Demand fell unexpectedly after a rival launched a remote diagnostic service, prompting Juniper to add remote triage; it retains its successful booking routine and abandons an uneconomic kiosk. Leaders want twice as many jobs within 18 months without measuring safe completion. Analyse strategic intent, actual strategy, levels, objectives and learning/structure needs. (10 marks)

Juniper case statements; labels are to be analysed, not given as answers.

Statement/actionTime or scope
Trusted regional repair networkFuture 2031
Appliance repair through trained teamsCurrent service
Honest diagnosis and safe workGuiding principles
Second service/capital allocationGroup-wide
Remote triage after rival launchUnexpected trigger
Show answer and marking
MarksCreditWorking / case application
2Intent/valuesFuture regional network is the vision; current appliance-repair service/customer/capabilities define mission. Honest diagnosis and safe work constrain choices. Do not recast the current service as a proven future market leader.
2Strategy mixPlanned service expansion, continued booking, reactive remote triage and abandoned kiosk explain the latest strategy. Reaction follows unforeseen rivalry; the cancelled kiosk is not an active element. The combined plan still requires evidence/resources.
2LevelsBoard portfolio/capital choices are corporate, repair division competitive service choice is business, and training courses are functional. Training staff also provide skill/capacity feedback, not merely receive orders.
2ObjectivesTwice as many jobs needs baseline, time/denominator and feasible capacity; safe completion/quality targets must correlate with growth. Use staged short-term milestones toward 18 months and evaluate actual outcomes, not job volume alone.
2Learning/networkCustomer/technician input and a bounded review address turbulent demand and costly/time-consuming analysis. A cross-functional triage project may use matrix roles if coordination gains justify dual-reporting costs; define accountability and never claim strategy guarantees success.

Original indicative capped marking, not official ICAI scheme. For two-mark rows: one mark for the sound concept and one for specific case application/reasoning. Equivalent justified answers accepted; no duplicate credit. Source conflicts and historical-example limits are recorded.

Official concept source, PDF page 6